AI Face and Plastic Surgery Expectations in Austin
For years, patients would come to me with pictures of Angelina Jolie’s jawline or Kim Kardashian’s nose. Then that shifted to filtered faces. Now what I’m seeing is that Instagram face is out, and AI face is in.
I’m Dr. Sarah Saxon, a double board-certified facial plastic surgeon in Austin, Texas. In my Austin practice, AI face images are showing up in consultations more often than they used to. Patients walk in with a generated picture of themselves and ask, is this possible? I want to explain what that request actually means, and why I won’t treat those pictures as a surgical plan.
If you’ve already read my post on how the “Instagram Face” look pushed certain procedures, this is the next version of that pressure. The pictures are more personal now, because they look like you.
Watch: “AI Face” Is the New Instagram Face
The First Time a Patient Brought Me a ChatGPT Image
The first time this happened in my practice, a patient put her photo into ChatGPT. She told it her goals, the things she wanted changed, and asked what it thought she needed, and what outcome she could expect.
It gave her an image that she showed me. It was not realistic. It didn’t even really look like her. We both had a little laugh, and we both understood that.
Other patients come in and really expect that picture to be the outcome they’re going for. If I can’t guarantee it, they may go to another surgeon who will set those expectations. That troubles me, because it plays into a false sense of what the human body can actually do.
What the Coverage Is Getting Right
This isn’t only something I’m seeing in clinic. In October 2026, Vogue Business published “Is AI Face the New Instagram Face?”, by Amy O’Brien, about patients using AI to mock up their own faces before surgery, and about the gap between that vision and what surgery can safely do.
Business Insider and The Guardian covered the same shift earlier in the year: people arriving with chatbot-generated “after” photos and asking surgeons to recreate them. The details vary from story to story. The pattern matches what I hear in Austin.
What AI Images Get Wrong About a Real Face
One thing I see over and over is the skin. In these images, it’s perfection. There’s no pore. There’s no line. It’s completely smooth under the eyes, with no shadows. That’s simply not possible.
No matter how much you tighten the skin or remove it, and no matter how many laser treatments you do, it’s never going to be completely flawless. We naturally have pores. We can do things to reduce them. We are never going to have zero pores on our skin.
I also see really sharp lines and very small features. The nose is often not proportional to the person’s face. It has no ethnic character to it at all. Sometimes the nostrils are so small that the nose wouldn’t function. You wouldn’t be able to breathe through it, and that’s not something most people want in the long term. If you’re thinking about rhinoplasty in Austin, function has to stay part of the plan, not an afterthought.
The jawline is another feature a lot of people point to. In these pictures it’s so sharp that no amount of pulling the skin tight, placing filler to camouflage and define it, or removing fat above or below the jaw will reach that perfected margin. Even when you see celebrity photos online and think, they have that result, so why can’t I, those images are usually filtered too, or run through software that morphs them a little.
Beauty Filters Already Change How We Judge Faces
There’s also research on how beauty filters shift our judgment, which helps explain why an AI “after” photo can feel so convincing.
In 2024, Gulati and colleagues published a study in Royal Society Open Science on the attractiveness halo effect in the era of beauty filters. They had 2,748 participants rate facial images of 462 people, first in an original condition and then after a beauty filter was applied. The same people received statistically significantly higher ratings of attractiveness after they were filtered. Ratings of other traits, including intelligence and trustworthiness, went up as well.
That study is about filters, not about surgical planning software. It still matters here. If a smoother, more “perfect” version of a face also starts to look smarter and more trustworthy, it becomes easier to treat that version as the real baseline, and your actual face as the problem.
The Risk of Chasing That Picture
The more you try to chase the perfection in these photos, the more you can end up with real harm. Repeated treatments can scar the skin. Too much skin can be removed, so a patient can’t close their eyes. Some people can no longer move their mouth normally, or move their face normally. Those are some of the telltale signs I see when someone has been chasing perfection.
I wrote about surgical risk in more detail in my posts on potential facelift complications and potential rhinoplasty complications. The point I want to make here is simpler. A picture that ignores anatomy is a poor guide for an operation that has to respect it.
Face-Rater Apps and the Looksmaxxing Trend
There’s even a new kind of app, one I believe is called LooksMax AI, where you can upload your image and get a rating, plus a list of procedures it says you need for a more “balanced” look. That plays into the trend of looksmaxxing.
Again, this can be a pretty dangerous road. If someone is already predisposed to body dysmorphia, it can push them into a more pathological state. It can also take someone who was not dysmorphic and make them so self-conscious of their image that they go on to have body dysmorphia. They use procedures to try to relieve some of that anxiety, and that never works. It’s a never-ending cycle, and it’s troubling.
If you’re trying to sort out the difference between a reasonable aesthetic concern and a more obsessive pattern, I explain that more fully in my post on dysmorphia versus dysphoria. An app score is not a diagnosis, and it is not a surgical plan.
When a Normal Feature Gets Treated Like a Flaw
I’ll be honest. It can be really difficult, as a facial plastic surgeon, to talk with some of my patients about this. Sometimes the expectation doesn’t come out until after surgery. If I had understood it beforehand, I would never have operated in the first place.
I’m talking about things like focusing millimeter by millimeter on the length of the upper lip, or on a small roll or line under the eye that isn’t completely gone. Even a four-year-old has a little bit of a roll there, because that’s a muscle that contracts to help close the eye.
The more we move the goalposts toward absolute perfection with facial anatomy, the more we’re going to see real negative outcomes from surgery. I already turn patients down when the request isn’t in their best interest, including some lip lift consultations where the goal would not serve them. AI images make those conversations harder, because the “after” photo looks so finished, and so personal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I bring my AI image to a consultation?
Yes, if it helps you show me what you’ve been looking at. I’d rather see the picture than have you quietly hope I’ll match it. We’ll use it to talk about what you like, and then I’ll tell you what is and isn’t realistic on your face.
Can surgery give me poreless skin and a razor-sharp jawline?
Not the way these images show it. Skin will still have pores, and a jawline has to work with your bone, your soft tissue, and how you move. Tightening, filler, fat removal, or a deep plane facelift can change definition. They cannot create the perfected edge you see in a generated photo.
Are face-rater or looksmaxxing apps a good way to plan surgery?
No. They can spit out a rating and a shopping list, but they don’t examine you, and they don’t know what would stay safe or look like you. If an app has you newly hating a feature you never noticed before, that’s useful information about distress, not a to-do list.
What does “AI face” actually mean?
I use it the way patients and recent coverage are using it: a computer-generated or heavily filtered version of a face, often your own, presented as a realistic surgical result. The lighting looks real. The features often aren’t.
I hope the trend of the AI face is just a phase, or that the technology eventually catches up with reality. As it stands right now, I would not trust an AI app to take the place of your surgeon in telling you what’s realistic for your goals.
The most important thing is to come see me, or another surgeon you trust, for recommendations based on your actual face and your actual goals. If you want to have that conversation in Austin, my team can help you get set up with a consultation. Bring the picture if you have one. We’ll still start with you, not with the algorithm.
About the Author

Dr. Sarah Saxon is a double board-certified facial plastic surgeon in Austin, Texas. Her practice is limited to the face, with a focus on deep plane facelifts, rhinoplasty, and helping patients set goals that still look like themselves.
You May Also Like:
- How to Prevent Buccal Fat Removal Regret
- Understanding Dysmorphia vs Dysphoria
- Why I Turn Down Some Lip Lift Patients
- 7 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Facelift Surgeon
- Rhinoplasty in Austin
- Deep Plane Facelift
References
- O’Brien A. Is AI Face the New Instagram Face? Vogue Business. October 13, 2026.
- Berg M. AI face is taking over and driving plastic surgeons crazy. Business Insider. May 16, 2026.
- Tomkins I. ‘You can’t control everything’: the rise in plastic surgeons asked to create ‘AI face’. The Guardian. May 23, 2026.
- Gulati A, Martínez-Garcia M, Fernández D, Lozano MA, Lepri B, Oliver N. What is beautiful is still good: the attractiveness halo effect in the era of beauty filters. R Soc Open Sci. 2024;11(11):240882.
This article is for general education and isn’t a substitute for a personal medical evaluation.